Wednesday, 5 July 2023

Life and Consciousness

The subject of consciousness is an interesting one since we use it all the time yet it remains completely mysterious. Science holds that consciousness arises from matter, while religion holds that matter arises from consciousness.

Science began the first time one of our ancestors gazed up into the stars and wondered. Yet, in spite of the way our telescopes have been able to see nearly back to the big bang, and our microscopes and particle accelerators have been able to probe into matter's heart, how consciousness works, what it is, and how it could arise from matter, remains unfathomable. 

Scientific ignorance about consciousness underlie the claims of Artificial Intelligence (AI). Biologists, who believe that consciousness depends on the human brain alone—consciousness arises from matter—have been arguing against consciousness in animals at the same time that computer scientists have been claiming that they are about to build conscious machines (again believing that consciousness arises from matter). Some (see Dennett 1971) have even enthused that their thermostats are conscious.

But what is consciousness? Mathematical physicist Sir Roger Penrose, of Oxford University, has shown that the world that we access through our consciousness appears to have an independent existence where the laws of mathematics, physics, chemistry, music, and conceivably other absolutes including ethics and beauty, exist outside of space and time.  Since it was Plato who first described it, it is called Plato's world—a place that can only be accessed by the intellect and that reveals itself to each of us through conscious reflection. Mathematical ideas unfold when we reflect upon them and they have also been found to underlie the physical world.

Consciousness appears, it reflects and finds Plato's world, and the truths found there lie behind the manifestation of the physical world. An example to illustrate this remarkable idea was presented by Penrose in his book The Emperor's New Mind. Though the idea that the number -1, minus one, could have a square root may be thought of as nothing more than a mathematical joke, since the squares of all numbers are positive, the square root of minus one, (√-1) has turned out to play a basic role in the operation of our universe at its tiniest scales. This argues powerfully for the reality of Plato's world--that place where things that are fundamentally true exist in an absolute sense. The illustration below shows the graph of an equation involving the square root of minus one: the Mandelbrot set. The second part shows it magnified a million times—the outline does not change with magnification, which is one of the characteristics of a fractal. The strange beauty of the graphed Mandelbrot set was always there, unknown to us, outside of space and time, until the calculating power of the computer allowed us to see it. There are many amazing images of it on the Internet, if you are interested and many other such intriguing graphs.

Roger Penrose also crafted a mathematical argument that machines would never be conscious, no matter how big or complex they might become, because consciousness lies in the region of non-computable things. He wrote that animals are likely conscious, and that consciousness likely involves the actions of sub-atomic particles—quantum mechanical phenomena—which do not follow the expectations of classical physics.

This could explain how fish and birds can be so intelligent, in spite of their small brains—the miniaturisation of the animal has not resulted in a loss of intelligence. Brain size, it seems, is unrelated to intelligence, implying that consciousness does not depend on mass.

There are other ways to access Plato's world. Though music is just vibration at different frequencies, pitch, and speed in the physical world, we respond to it sub­jectively and perceive it as beautiful. We all agree on the qualities of its different styles—slow music played in a minor key is sad, fast music in a major key is cheerful or rousing, and so forth. That this response is shared among us, provides further evidence of the independent reality of Plato's world. 

Other animals respond to music too. Birds use some of the same harmonies, rhythms, beats and scales as human musicians, (though their music may be performed many times faster than ours), which suggests that birds can also access Plato's world. A hermit thrush's song, when played at one-­quarter speed, sounds like a human composition that has between forty-­five to one hundred notes and twenty-­five to fifty pitch changes. It approximates a pentatonic scale with all the harmonic intervals.  

Depending on the species, each individual bird creates his own songs, and some compose hundreds and perfect them single-­mindedly. Occa­sionally one achieves an aria. 

Birds seem to enjoy singing and will sing in duets and groups. A singing flock will at times be joined in their tree by other flocks, of other species, who add their voices to the symphony.

As in humans, the artistic ability seems to be partly hereditary, and partly due to the efforts of the bird to improve his performance in comparison with an inner concept of the musically beauti­ful, which he or she found, presumably, in Plato’s world.

Animals seem to be aware of visual beauty, too. The bowers of bowerbirds resemble art. They are created by the males, who search out a variety of coloured objects with which to decorate them, and proceed like a human artist, alternately placing the coloured pieces, then standing back and surveying the effect, as if guided by an inner idea of the most attractive arrangements. I was lucky to have observed this in Australia.

Animals including elephants and apes have learned to paint pictures and seem to enjoy doing so. Apes and bears have been reported to go to a lookout to watch the sunset, and one of my jungle­ fowls spent each evening on the beach, intermittently looking across the shimmering sea towards the setting sun. When he was dying, his last act was to get up from his bed, stagger to the window, and gaze out across those glowing waters one last time.

Reflection on life's processes suggests other curious facts.

In nature, each instance of animal behaviour always presents as an individual in a specific situ­ation. This is the essence of the evolutionary process, as a population of a given species, depending upon the ingenuity and resilience of its individuals—especially its unusual individuals—adapts to changing surroundings. It is the choices and effort of each individual that drives evolution, as they succeed or fail to reproduce and pass on their special genes to their descendants. As in human communities, unusual animals can have a powerful influence on others and on the culture, as anyone who observes wild animals and their communities soon finds. 

The flight capabilities of birds have been documented through the fossil record to have evolved slowly as each generation tried to stay in the air as long as possible. Con­sider what must have taken place. At first, just the ability to hop higher, with the fore­limbs reach­ing up, must have begun the transition as the creature fled from increasingly nimble predators. Gradually, gliding developed, as only those who were able to leap the highest reproduced. At last, over aeons of strife by each individual trying to survive, wings evolved.

Thus, birds have wings because they fly—the behaviour comes before the structure—and in this sense it is consciousness that gives rise to matter. Following this line of reasoning leads to a picture in which the species have created themselves, each being a manifestation of all of the efforts of all of the individuals down through the abyss of time since life appeared. Even those who were eaten by predators had their role, for they helped others to survive.

Now, evidence of cognitive capabilities has been found in bacteria, amoeba, paramecia, and plants, as well as those we consider to be the “higher animals.” Awareness in a one celled animal suggests that it might be an intrinsic aspect of life itself, and not dependent on the complexity of the animal's nervous system. It could be a long time before the phenomenon of consciousness is understood, but as long as its source remains unknown, no conclusions denying it to animals can be drawn. 

This brings us to the general subject of wild animal behaviour, which is what I created this blog to write about. These first three articles are meant to provide some background—to set the scene—before we move on to accounts of what some specific wild animals are doing. I hope you enjoyed them and will join me as we go on to yet more intriguing things!

(c) Ila France Porcher

Author of Birds are Impossible: The Supernatural Ways of the Fliers.

 

Thursday, 25 May 2023

A Brief History of Earth

Protected by the most delicate film of atmosphere, our planet spins alone in a near vacuum of chilling darkness for an eternity of spacetime in all directions, where, apparently, nothing lives and no consciousness wonders. In all the universe, no other planet has been located that is anything like ours—that has even a remote possibility of sustaining what we know as complex life. At least we can be sure of this within 100,000 light-years of Earth. And that's a long way. Yet life has found myriad ways to flourish, no matter what happened, since it mysteriously made its start, here on Earth. 

Pursuing my wildlife artist’s lifestyle, I was always roaming the wilderness. The interior plateau rolled northward like waves upon a great sea and there the sky opened wide. At night I would lie half dreaming, glued flat on my back to the surface of our beloved planet, too awed to sleep. Gazing away into the diamond galaxy, as it swept through the black satin background, I felt right at the centre of a universe of wonders. What could be happening at this moment out there, what unimaginable event? When one looks out in this way, human life’s concerns grow dim; it is obvious that in general, up and down has no meaning. Reality consists instead of radiating, gravitating centres, whirling for eternity along invisible paths. There are more stars than grains of sand upon the earth, in galaxies without number, some with gigantic black holes at their centres. There are quasars whose cores are black holes of the mass of many billions of our sun, in a single point 10-43 cm across. There are young stars, old stars, red giants, white dwarfs, and exploding stars.

And you know that what is out there is something terrific, whether or not one of us humble creatures can understand it. As some mystics are wont to say, “Behold the true dragon!”

We are flying at a speed of thirty kilometres per second around the sun, which is moving around our galaxy, the Milky Way, at several hundred kilometres per second. The Milky Way moves against the background radiation at a speed of 600 kilometres per second, or one fifth of a percent of the speed of light. Yet I feel perfectly still, without even a breath of wind to suggest movement—so much of what we perceive is only an apparency. In fact, there is no such thing as absolute stillness; all movement is relative.

To look out through the universe is to look into the past, since the light revealing it took time to reach us. Therefore, space is measured by the distance light travels in a year, called a light-year; it is impossible to separate space and time. Scientists believe, through many meticulous measurements and calculations, that the universe banged into being 13.7 billion years ago—plus or minus 200 million years—and flew outwards at a rate that had nothing to do with the usual speed limit. The rule that nothing can travel faster than light does not apply to the expansion of spacetime. The observable universe (the part from which light has had time to reach us), is about 28 billion light years across.

Using modern telescopes, scientists can see back in time almost to the big bang, though that mysterious beginning is veiled in the fog that existed before atoms formed and the universe became transparent. However, astronomers have found very old galaxies that formed soon after, from irregularities in spacetime. Those first stars grew old and when they exploded, they scattered the heavier elements we know as matter across the expanding universe. Another unimaginable abyss of time passed as the action of gravitational forces caused this material to cluster, and form a second generation of stars, many with revolving discs around them, as rock, dust, ices, and gases drew together in an ever-turning aggregate. Thus our our planetary system eventually formed—about five billion years ago. 

We live in a changing, evolving universe.

Earth formed about four and a half billion years ago as the third of the nine planets in the disc orbiting our newborn sun. The new planet was in wild turmoil due to gravitational forces acting on the different densities of matter tumbling inwards. While debris rained from the skies and lakes of lava exploded, blocks of rock were thrust to the surface, ices melted and boiled, and heavier material sank. For a long period it was a hot, explosive place, littered with active volcanoes, and running with lava.

Slowly Earth cooled and its geological features became more settled. After a billion years, it was cool enough that the steamy atmosphere had mostly condensed and rained into a planet-wide ocean. Carbon dioxide precipitated out of the atmosphere, leaving it mostly nitrogen. The sky was cloudy. Earth was still hot inside and volcanoes continued to pour lava to the surface, some forming islands in the ocean. The crust of the planet contracted as it cooled, and the powerful and turbulent forces of the molten rock within forced some regions up to form mountain ranges, and caused others to crack or sink. With the passage of time, chains of islands were pushed together and continents began to take shape.

How life got started is not yet understood, for only life grows more, and not less, orderly. (The tendency for things to fall apart is self-evident and completely irreversible in all but living things.)

Once life was here, it began to change its environment. The fossil record reveals that single-celled cyanobacteria were the first life forms, 3.7 billion years ago. They floated in the hot and shallow ocean—doing nothing much—but they produced oxygen, and claimed this spinning aggregate of rock, fire, water, and gases for life. After two billion years, enough oxygen had collected to turn the sky blue, and there was a breathable atmosphere that could support complex life forms. Our life-supporting atmosphere was created by life itself.

In all that time there had been life, but death waited. For those first aeons, life consisted of single-celled forms that reproduced by cell division—a continuous existence with no death and no change. Until, deep in this interminable peace, somehow two cells merged before dividing, sexual reproduction began, and, 1.7 billion years ago, death appeared.

It was death, with his side-kick, sex, that launched evolution's race. Now, each new individual was endowed with his or her very own combination of genes to play in the chances of life, and only the excellent won the right to reproduce.

Suddenly, life diversified dramatically. Death cleared away all who could not keep up, which was nearly everyone. Molluscs, seaweeds, sponges, coral, starfish, sea-lilies, plankton, algae, shrimps, crabs—a whole array of invertebrate life—sprang into being. Some life forms developed photosynthesis, which continued the production of oxygen, and half a billion years ago, plants appeared and covered the land, while the first vertebrates emerged. Able to support themselves against the pull of gravity, animals could finally leave the waters.

Ninety percent of the entire history of Earth was required to set the scene—to prepare a stable, compatible place for complex life to flower. Another eternity passed while a variety of life forms evolved and vanished, before dinosaurs dominated the Earth 260 million years ago. 

Though they were a victim of a mass extinction 65 million years ago, some are still with us in the form of birds, having evolved considerably in the meantime.

All of us living today descended from the best, the smartest and the strongest individuals from each generation, for all of that time. Many more died than lived to reproduce, but every single one of our ancestors managed to make it to adulthood, AND have kids! What a test. If only we knew of all of their stories, their strife, and their lucky breaks. . .

The latest counts tell us that about nine hundred million species of higher life forms share the planet with us, networking in an intricately inter-tangled play of individuals, large and tiny, which form life’s endless community. From frozen poles, to tropical jungles, to the oceanic abyss, each creature is at the centre of its own world view of events, each challenged by survival. Green plants link the earth to the sun’s energy. Using photosynthesis, they mix sunlight with water and Earth to grow leaves, flowers, and fruit. Physically and chemically intertwined with the air, they recycle water to fall as rain and stream from the forest fringes, back to the sea. The oceans circulate in a cycle taking a thousand years, keeping our climate stable, while, through evaporation, water puffs back into the atmosphere and blows in the winds, forming clouds to rain again upon the land. And forces beyond the power of our imaginations have permitted this spinning globe to rest stably so that we have all had the chance to pursue our lives.

The numbers of life forms who have played out their existences on Earth is unimaginable, as the sun rose and set, and things happened, for them as for us. Did all of these creatures not understand, however simply, the world in which they found themselves? Can consciousness only have existed since our own species emerged? When did life on Earth begin to feel and wonder?

We live in a universe that remains mysterious, after all!

(c) Ila France Porcher

Author of Birds are Impossible: The Supernatural Ways of the Fliers, Outwitted by Chickens: The Bird Who Killed the Tiger and The Spirit of Wild Ducks

Monday, 22 May 2023

The Majesty of Life

The great mystery of life and its majesty here on Earth is a theme in my thinking these days, so I decided to create this blog to write about it. If you are reading these words, welcome. I hope you will enjoy exploring some of these ideas with me. 

 
Life has become harder since the pandemic and many people are feeling pessimistic. But beauty is worth living for. It is everywhere, as if it is one of those basic attributes of nature—as if the very physical laws cause it as they play upon the universe.
 
 
If the study of the universe has taught us anything, it is surely how precious life is. The intricate network of living things that covers our planet from pole to pole is like a jewel, while reality, for countless light-years in all directions, consists of uninhabitable chilling darkness and incomprehensible gravitational sinks. So is there not every reason to consider the manifestation of life here, in this planetary system, to be remarkable? Never has it been more important to recognize the true nature of the biosphere and treat it with all of the wisdom with which we pride ourselves.
 
Life on our planet started as soon as it settled down enough to provide stable conditions. Energy, water, air, and a variety of complex molecules came together and organized themselves into increasingly complex structures. Yet they did this in defiance of the law that decrees that entropy—disorganization—must always increase. How the elements of life, alone, could possibly have defied this basic law of physics remains a mystery to science. As is life’s strange manifestation: the mystical elixir of consciousness. 
 
Through all of my years watching the actions of wild animals, if one thing has seemed inarguable, it is that we share consciousness with the other forms of life. Consciousness of the same reality appears to be the medium that permits living things to interact appropriately. Reality makes sense to us all because we are all conscious of it, and this shared understanding is the ground for interaction among individuals and species.
 
Indeed, the spirits of nature and humanity are interwoven upon our spectacular planet. 
 
Now, scientific evidence of consciousness is being found in increasing numbers of species—not only in dolphins, crows, and apes, but also in octopuses, plants, bacteria, moulds, and amoebas. It presents as a fundamental aspect of life—an awareness of the objective world in which the life form understands its environment and deliberately furthers its interests as it pursues its existence.
 
We are enraptured by the unicorn of the imagination, but is not life itself the miracle?
 
The delicacy, the beauty of the biosphere, conveys something of the underlying quality of the consciousness behind it. The peacock, for example, in its quest to become beautiful, did not just grow a radiant plume to attract the gaze—it evolved a fabulous fan of intricately designed feathers, each detailed to the microscopic level, all fitting together to produce a breathtaking over-all design. Then there is the intricate and precise colouration of butterflies. Their flamboyant patterns tell us something of the minds of these delicate life forms who, through aeons of evolution, have chosen their dress.
 
 

The beguiling beauty of Nature on Earth is well beloved by its inhabitants. 
 
Each creature, even the tiniest, is an individual with his or her personal ways. Including snakes.

I chose the title of this blog as a way of saying, Fear not. Fear is one of the things that has stood between modern humans and nature, but it is a phantom, a ghost. Animals will not hurt you if you do not hurt them as I know from many years of wandering the wilderness alone, both above and underwater. Indeed, it is us who are the dangerous ones. 

So take heart and behold the majesty, the transcendental splendour, of Earth!

(c) Ila France Porcher 

Ethologist, Author and Wildlife Artist